The Faculty is delighted to welcome the news that PhD student Jonathan Chu has been awarded the Society of Legal Scholars (SLS) prize for Best Paper at the recent SLS Annual Conference at the University of East Anglia in September.
Papers were nominated by convenors of the SLS subject sections and judged by a panel consisted of Professor Claudina Richards (SLS Immediate Past President), Professor Niamh Dunne (representative of Legal Studies, SLS’s journal) and Professor Nicola Wake (SLS Vice-President). Jonathan's paper, 'The Merger Fallacy Diagnosed: Debt, Judgement and Security', was presented in the Remedies and Restitution section co-convened by Dr Rachel Leow and Dr Timothy Liau.
Jonathan’s paper examines the interrelationship between a contractual debt and a money judgment, challenging the traditional view that judgments extinguish debts by "merging" them. Drawing on principles of security law, the paper argues that the recovery of a money judgment merely precludes further court actions on the same debt while leaving the debt itself untouched. The paper also traces the history of this doctrine of “merger in judgment”, identifies possible sources of misunderstanding, and explores the continuing influence which this misunderstanding exerts on contemporary legal thought and judicial practice.
The paper grows out of Jonathan’s ongoing doctoral research in which he seeks to develop an understanding of monetary rights and responsibilities that can better explain English law, beyond the paradigm of their enforceability through a money judgment.
Jonathan’s research is conducted under the joint supervision of Professor Graham Virgo and Professor Lionel Smith (Oxford).